Menu Contact
Tilford Dobbins & Schmidt, PLLC
Call
502-584-1000
For A Consultation
Practice Areas Menu

How does wrongful termination relate to constructive discharge?

Each workday in offices across America, employees may suffer bullying or harassment from co-workers or superiors until they can no longer endure working for the company. These employees, due to extreme stress, cannot continue to function in an increasingly hostile and degrading work environment.

Complaints to the worker's Human Resources professional seldom bring results. HR personnel have an unfortunate conflict of interest. A company that may turn a blind eye to bullying and harassment pays their salary; therefore, HR balks at getting involved in a dispute between a low-level employee and the company that holds HR's loyalty financially hostage.

To be fair to HR personnel, it is not easy for an employee to provide evidence of the harassment. Bullies are very good at hostile, provoking behavior when no one is around to see it. HR understandably may decline to stir up troubled waters unless they have solid evidence that something is wrong. 

How is discharge a constructive behavior? 

The word "constructive" suggests something that is "positive, useful or helpful" to the average person. In the practice of law, the term "constructive discharge" means that, when a person quits a job because of intolerable working conditions, it is the same as if the company fired that person. The legal reasoning is that the company's cruelty forced the employee to quit.

It is common practice for some businesses to force older employees, whistleblowers or minority workers to quit by unsavory tactics such as bullying by management, harassment by co-workers through malicious gossip, derogatory comments or direct verbal insults to the person, sabotage of the employee's work followed by an accusation of incompetence, or assigning more work than any person could complete during the workday. There are many devious ways a company can get rid of an older person who is making a good salary after years of employment so they can hire a young worker for less pay and fewer benefits. Employers who disapprove of a worker's gender, religion, appearance or ethnic culture may force them out of the company

When does constructive discharge equal wrongful termination? 

The law protects people from wrongful dismissal by an employer. The company may try to say they had nothing to do with the employee's decision to leave. Most reasonable workers will eventually leave a job when singled out for relentless, unfair treatment or public humiliation. The boss may micromanage or scold them like a child because a manager or company executive wants that person to quit. The person may experience offensive "jokes" or discriminatory remarks. The manager and co-workers may give the employee the silent treatment and withhold materials he or she needs to complete assigned duties.

When a worker ponders whether to quit an impossible job or has already walked away, it is important to consult an employment professional about legal options. An unethical company cannot get away with causing or tolerating abusive treatment. American workers have the right to dispute unfair employment tactics.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Call 502-584-1000 to speak to a lawyer today.

  1. Charles W. Dobbins, Jr.

    Charles earned his J.D. degree from the University of Virginia in 1974

    He was graduated from Washington & Lee University in 1970 with a B.A. with Distinction

    Read More

    Mark W. Dobbins

    Mark earned his B.A. from Emory University.

    He earned his J.D. from the University of Louisville.

    Read More

    Patrick T. Schmidt

    Patrick earned his B.S. in Accounting from the University of Kentucky in 1989.

    He earned his J.D. from the University of Kentucky in 1992.

    Read More

    Terrence L. McCoy

    Terry earned a B.A. from Dartmouth College in 1964.

    He earned his J.D. from Duke University in 1967.

    Read More

    Lisa Koch Bryant

    Ms. Bryant has extensive commercial litigation and bankruptcy experience. Prior to entering private practice, Ms. Bryant served as head of litigation for the Federal Land Bank of Louisville.

    Read More
  2. Wm. Stephen Reisz

    Thomas graduated from the University of Louisville Business School with a B.A. in 1973

    Thomas earned his J.D. degree from the

    Read More

    Sandra F. Keene

    Sandra earned her Bachelor of Health Science degree, with Honors, from the University of Louisville in 1982.

    She earned her J.D. degree from the

    Read More

    Elizabeth M. Jenkins

    Colgate University, B.A., Political Science, magna cum laude, 1983

    University of Virginia, J.D., 1992

    Read More

    Edward L. Galloway

    Ed graduated from Indiana University in 1967 with a degree in history.

    After obtaining a master’s degree in political science from the University of

    Read More

    Thomas G. Karageorge

    Thomas graduated from the University of Louisville Business School with a B.A. in 1973

    Thomas earned his J.D. degree from the

    Read More
  3. Tacasha E. Thomas

    Tacasha attended Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts during the summer of 2001, where she studied courses in law and psychology.

    Read More

    Ayala Golding

    Ayala received her J.D. in 1994 from the University of Louisville, Louis D. Brandeis School of Law, Louisville, Kentucky, where she was a member of the Brandeis Family Law Journal, and

    Read More

    Kacie A. Wilkinson

    Kacie A. Wilkinson recently joined Tilford, Dobbins & Schmidt, PLLC, where she practices in the areas of business law & transactions, real estate, estate planning and probate.

    Read More

    Gwendolyn Chidester

    Gwen recently joined the Firm after being employed by notable Louisville companies for over 15 years in a variety of capacities including Corporate Counsel, Director of Human Resources, and Risk Manager.

    Read More

    William A. Buckaway, Jr.

    Bill earned his B.A. from Centre College in Kentucky in 1956.

    He earned his J.D. from the University of Louisville in 1961 where he was a

    Read More

    Terrell L. Black

    Terry earned a B.S. in Social Science from Campbellsville College in 1966.

    In 1969, he attended graduate school at Eastern Kentucky University focusing on

    Read More

    John A. Wilmes

    John was admitted to the Kentucky bar in 1977 and admitted to practice before the U.S. District Court, Western District of Kentucky in 1979.

    Read More

Contact Us

401 West Main Street, Suite 1400
Louisville, KY 40202

Phone: 502-513-0600
Phone: 502-584-1000
Fax: 502-584-2318
Louisville Law Office Map